PPC Live #22: Understand The Wider Business, Move Beyond Your Channel

While each speaker approached the topic from a different angle, my biggest takeaway was that great PPC isn't just about managing campaigns. It's about understanding the wider business: how leads generate value, where growth is being constrained, what drives profit, and how PPC fits alongside other channels. In this article, I'll recap the key points from each talk and why they matter.
Talk 1: Laura Abreu - Your Target CPA Might Be Holding You Back
Laura kickstarted the event by asking us whether our target CPA is preventing growth. The logic is that if you’re focused so heavily on cost that you set (for example) a $100 CPA, you cut off your access to valuable customers, who might cost slightly more (e.g., $150) to acquire, but give a stronger return. You may find yourself chasing cheaper leads that are worth less to the business (e.g., a person that fills out a lead form, or attends an intro call, but never becomes a customer).
This is made worse if you don’t know why the target CPA exists as you may be bidding towards an arbitrary target that doesn’t need to be as low as it is, or leaning on a tCPA when lead values differ significantly, resulting in Google treating all conversions similarly despite some being far more valuable than others.
She explained that most tCPAs come from historical account performance, a Google recommendation, or what the account has always used. But, as mentioned above, none of these account for the value a business wants to generate.

To decide whether tCPA is a good fit or not, she shared 4 key questions we can ask:
Does the target come from what a lead is worth? If it isn’t, you can figure this out by engaging with sales, finance, and the owner(s) of the business to understand how many leads become customers, what the value of those is, and how much the business is willing to pay to win one.
Is the budget fixed and spent in full every day? If yes, consider switching to Maximise Conversions, where Google can optimise toward the highest volume of conversions within the available budget.
Do lead values differ from the CRM that tracks them? If yes, consider switching to value-based bidding. This prevents setting the same tCPA for a customer who’ll bring in $1000 a year vs. a bunch of low value/quality leads that will bring in $300.
Are the targets justified, does the budget have room, and are leads alike? Consider keeping the target and keeping a record of why the target is justified.
Talk 2: Susan Yen - Scaling Isn’t The Same As Growth
Susan followed up by reminding us that scaling marketing is not the same as growing a business. A client may want to increase conversions by expanding budget or channels, but this doesn’t necessarily result in more profit.
If the client doesn’t have the marketing & business systems to track or capture leads (for example), or invest enough to achieve meaningful results in a channel (for instance), the risk is increasing spend, with little return.

Before rushing to activate new channels or spend more money, she recommends initiating communication with the client to understand what their actual ask is:
What outcome are we growing? For example, is the customer seeking more leads?
Why now & what changed?
Can we prove leads are turning into customers?
Where is the biggest leak? (gives you an indication of what to fix & which solutions will work).
What must be true first?
What’s the smallest real test?
Once you’ve communicated with the client, you can map the following &a decide on what the actual constraint is, then design a structured approach to testing.
The actual constraint: Is the client not getting enough conversions because they’re not spending enough, not investing in enough channels, or because they’re not tracking what happens after the click & which leads actually turn into customers who generate value?
Foundations/prep: If the foundations are the issue, look to improve measurement and sales team capacity (or fix any other constraint).
Testing: Run an experiment with clear success and failure criteria. From there, you can choose to scrap, scale, or iterate.
Validate: Prove the quality & economy of the leads (e.g., after investing in a new channel).
Scale: Only repeat an approach (e.g., continue investing in a new channel) if you’re seeing that the quality of the leads and the actual value generated is good enough.
If you do decide you need to expand, you can use this decision rule to test new & existing channels and make a decision about whether to keep or park channels & investment levels:
Hypothesis: What need are we testing?
Audience: Who, and why act?
Measurement: Which outcomes count?
Guardrails: Budget, time, baseline?
Decisions: Stop, iterate, or scale.
Talk 3: Jeremy Young - What Profit Data Can Really Do
Jeremy challenged the assumption that revenue and ROAS alone are enough to evaluate success. He shared a case-study of an account that appeared successful on the surface, with a 10.4x ROAS.

However, when he dug deeper, he found the following issues:
Brand bleed: 28% of spend was branded & brand spend was found across non-brand campaigns.
New/Existing Customers: Nobody could state what it cost
to win a customer or whether the account was re-selling to existing customers.
Tracking: Conversion tracking wasn’t reliable, reporting was on revenue (not profit), and the business platform had issues.
Spend wasn’t scaling: Increases in spend led to flat revenue & profit.
To fix this, he conducted a full account audit (tracking, structure, feed, etc.), split brand from non-brand, rebuilt the feed, and pulled in order-level profit. Order-level profit was integral, as it helped with the following:
Campaign evaluation: Helped with understanding that high-ROAS, low margin stock was less valuable.
Budget allocation: The ability to invest budget in SKUs that generate profit (vs. revenue).
Segmentation: Structuring Shopping by profitability tier & splitting own brand products out from reseller.
Bidding strategy: Google was able to optimise towards margin using POAS targets.
The ability to evaluate campaigns & move budgets towards the most profitable areas helped improve performance (+79% in net profit in Jeremy’s case study). This also helped build a stronger case for increased investment and budget growth. Ultimately, Jeremy's view was that profit data matters and that relying solely on revenue and ROAS can be misleading. He also demonstrated how profit data can be used beyond bidding, emphasising that incorporating profit into bid strategies is just one application, not the only one.
Talk 4: James Bavington - The Questions Brand Leaders Are Asking
James tackled a number of questions currently being asked by brand leaders, including whether ChatGPT is replacing Google, where organic traffic has gone, and how Paid and Organic teams should work together as AI becomes more prominent. Whilst AI adoption continues to grow, his view was that ChatGPT isn't replacing Google (6 Google searches for every 1 ChatGPT prompt). Instead, AI is becoming another research touchpoint that consumers use alongside traditional search engines. Most AI-assisted shopping journeys still involve a search engine at some point, suggesting AI is changing how people research rather than replacing search behaviour entirely.

He also challenged the perception that organic traffic is disappearing. He argued that clicks are being redistributed across Search features such as AI Overviews, Shopping results, paid ads and product grids. As these features occupy more space on the SERP, fewer clicks are naturally available to traditional organic listings. As a result, James argued that Paid and Organic teams can no longer afford to operate separately. He recommended collaborating in four key areas:
Measurement: Use shared KPIs and assess visibility across paid, organic and AI surfaces rather than reviewing channels independently. Shared dashboards help with this.
Content and feeds: Treat websites, product feeds and product data as shared assets. These increasingly power Shopping, AI experiences and automated campaign types.
Brand strategy: Paid and Organic should collaborate to measure the impact of switching Paid off with incrementality tests.
AI visibility: Monitor how brands appear in AI-generated answers and identify opportunities to improve visibility where appropriate.
Ultimately, his view was that Paid and Organic teams should be measuring, testing and planning together. As search becomes more fragmented across Google, AI and Shopping experiences, success will depend less on channel-specific metrics and more on overall visibility across the search ecosystem.
Wrapping Up

Looking back across all four talks, a common theme emerged: PPC performance can't be viewed in isolation. Whether we're evaluating lead quality, identifying business constraints, measuring profitability or adapting to changing search behaviour, the most valuable insights often come from outside the advertising platform itself. The stronger our understanding of the wider business, the better positioned we are to make decisions that drive meaningful growth.

















Comments